In this post we discuss the topic of whether IRA owners should take more than their Required Minimum Distributions (RMDs) in order to have the family pay less overall income and capital gains tax, and to protect accounts from nursing home costs.
My best guess is that more than 90% of IRA owners elect to take only their Required Minimum Distributions from their Traditional IRA. It seems that the only people who take more than the RMD are those who need the money to spend it.
What many don't realize is that the net amount to family is often not as much as it could be when IRA owners take only their RMDs. The rational goes something like this: When an IRA owner takes RMDs only, it is likely there will be a taxable IRA that will be left to beneficiaries. The beneficiaries must pay income tax on distributions they get from their Inherited IRA - sure, they can postpone distributions but they will still pay income tax on these postponed distributions.
However, an IRA owner whose taxable distributions exceed the RMDs, so much so that the entire IRA is depleted, will be able to invest these after tax proceeds in such a manner that the appreciation on those after-tax investments will never be taxed, due to the step-up in basis rule.
The kicker comes when an IRA owner wants to protect their IRA from nursing home expenses. When they take only the RMDs, it will create a situation that when they enter a nursing home, they will still own an IRA and will be forced to take distrubtions, pay income tax, and spend the after-tax proceeds on their nursing home care until they have less than $2,000, leaving virtually nothing for their heirs or designated beneficiaries.
However, the IRA owner who took larger IRA distributions, paid taxes, and put after-tax proceeds in a Medicaid qualifying Grantor Trust will protect those assets from future nursing home expenses, and will maximize what goes to the beneficiaries income tax free and capital gains tax free.
While I understand that people don't want to pay tax until the positively, absolutely have to, perhaps some thought should go into whether an IRA should take only the RMDs that are required, or whether they should take out more than the RMDs, and invest the after-tax proceeds in a manner that is both protected from nursing home spend-down, and income or capital gains tax at death.
This post is for informational purposes only and does not provide legal advice. Please do not act or refrain from acting based on anything you read on this site. Using this site or communicating with Rabalais Estate Planning, LLC, through this site does not form an attorney/client relationship.
Louisiana Estate Planning Attorney
Phone: (225) 329-2450